Theft

Being charged with theft in Nashville or the surrounding counties can seriously impact your future. Even a low-level accusation like shoplifting may lead to a criminal record that affects your job, housing, and reputation. More serious allegations can bring jail time, fines, or felony convictions.

Working with a theft lawyer can make a real difference when the stakes are this high. Legal representation allows you to challenge the evidence, protect your rights, and explore outcomes that reduce the impact of the charge. This can involve reducing the charge, avoiding a conviction, or resolving the case through diversion.

We’ve defended individuals facing theft charges across Nashville and Middle Tennessee for over twenty years. As a former Assistant District Attorney in Davidson County, Bryan Stephenson understands how these cases move through local courts. He personally handles each case and builds strong defenses grounded in the law and the facts, not assumptions.

Understanding Theft Charges in Tennessee

Tennessee law defines theft as knowingly obtaining or exercising control over someone else’s property without permission and with the intent to keep it from the rightful owner. The charge type depends on the item or service’s value. Penalties can vary from a fine to multiple years in prison.

Property valued at $1,000 or less is charged as a misdemeanor. However, theft over that amount may lead to felony charges. For instance, if the property is worth between $1,000 and $2,500, the charge becomes a Class E felony. Higher values result in more severe charges.

Theft offenses that are commonly prosecuted in Nashville include:

• Shoplifting from retail stores
• Not returning a rental car on time
• Taking personal property from homes or vehicles
• Employee theft or misuse of business assets
• Possession of stolen property
• Alleged scams involving services or digital goods

What often gets overlooked is how quickly these charges can escalate. A misunderstanding or an accusation based on weak evidence can lead to a serious legal matter. Police reports, witness statements, or video footage are not always complete or accurate. In many cases, some details deserve closer inspection.

The role of a theft attorney is to challenge the case at every step. This includes reviewing how the arrest occurred, whether your rights were violated, and what the prosecution relies on. If the facts do not support the charge, your attorney will push for the case to be dropped. If a trial becomes necessary, your attorney will prepare a defense designed to raise reasonable doubt.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does the value of the item matter in a theft case?

Yes. The charge and penalty are based on the value of what was allegedly taken. Lower-value items may result in misdemeanor charges, while higher amounts often lead to felonies. Sometimes, the value of the property is over-inflated and subject to challenge.

Can theft charges be expunged?

Some theft charges may be eligible for expungement, especially if the case was dismissed or resolved through a diversion program. Eligibility depends on the outcome and the individual’s prior record.

Will I go to jail for a first-time theft offense?

Not always. In many cases, a first-time offense can be resolved without jail. Outcomes vary based on the facts, the value involved, your criminal history, and how early you begin working with a qualified theft attorney.

What if I was accused but never took anything?

Intent is a key part of a theft charge. If there is no clear evidence that you intended to keep the property, challenging or reducing the charge may be possible.

Take the First Step Toward a Stronger Defense

A theft accusation can disrupt your life and future. You may feel pressure, embarrassment, and uncertainty before a court date. These cases can move quickly, especially in Nashville and nearby counties, and the wrong steps early on can have lasting consequences.

At the Law Office of Bryan Stephenson, we approach every theft case with careful attention to detail and a commitment to protecting your rights. With experience on both sides of the courtroom, we know how these cases are prosecuted and how to build an effective response.

If you or someone you know is facing theft charges in Nashville, Davidson County, or Williamson County, we encourage you to take action now. Visit the Law Office of Bryan Stephenson to learn more or contact our office to schedule a consultation.